In this reflective "Because" episode of To Be and Do, Phil Amerson revisits a pivotal period serving as pastor at Broadway United Methodist Church in Indianapolis, sharing personal anecdotes and hard-earned wisdom about building a truly welcoming church community. Weaving together Biblical references, personal stories, and social observations, the episode confronts the realities and aspirations involved in embracing multiculturalism—both in faith communities and society at large.

Key Themes

1. The Challenge and Commitment of Multicultural Community

Phil highlights the ambitious and intentional mission statement adopted by Broadway United Methodist Church in 1986: to become a multicultural Christian community that seeks, welcomes, and values all people. This brings out a theme of aspiration versus lived reality. Despite admitting their naivety in striving for such ideals celebrates the commitment to inclusivity that has endured for 40 years , even as the community grappled with hard lessons and social challenges.

2. Confronting the Power of Fear and Tribalism

The episode does not shy away from acknowledging the forces that undermine multicultural efforts. Speaker B discusses how tribalism, fear, and resentment have historically eroded goodwill—not just within their church, but across society and global alliances . In one vivid example , manifestations of discrimination and bigotry are likened to masked ICE agents in urban America, underscoring the persistent threats to genuine inclusion. Yet, the congregation’s mission remains a countercultural witness to God’s love for all neighbors .

3. The Enduring Value of Hope and Long-Term Faithfulness

Despite setbacks and societal cynicism, Phil questions whether such aspirations are truly naive. Drawing from the teachings of Paul and referencing Eugene Peterson’s phrase, “a long obedience in the same direction” , the episode encourages listeners to persist in the slow work of building loving, inclusive communities. The ultimate message is not to lose hope or retreat into isolation, but to keep striving for the reality of God’s kingdom on earth.

Notable Quotes

• “The gift of knowing others who differed in a community of acceptance could never be erased.” (03:40)
• “Stay at it, good friends. Don’t get stuck in privatism or self pity.” (04:29)

Tune in for a thoughtful meditation on faith, community, and the courage required to love beyond boundaries.