"Because" - No One Is Garbage in God’s Realm: An Advent Conversation
In this deeply reflective "Because" episode of To Be and Do, Philip Amerson offer listeners a moving meditation rooted in the Advent season. Through compassionate conversation, poetry, and powerful personal observations, the episode challenges us to examine how we wield power, embrace paradox, and recognize the inherent dignity in every person—especially during a time of year that calls for hope, introspection, and transformation.
The episode opens with Philip Amerson introducing “The Belonging Exchange,” and sharing how a poem by Walter Wangren Jr. has been a catalyst for wrestling with questions of power, authority, and belonging in today’s turbulent socio-political climate. There’s candid acknowledgment of the injustices and harmful rhetoric that dominate public discourse—when even national leaders refer to people as “garbage” or when violence is justified by questionable motives. Both speakers invite listeners to resist the numbing effect of these narratives and instead, seek the courage to “live beyond the easy either-or” thinking that divides neighbor from neighbor.
Throughout the episode, Philip Amerson reminds us of Advent’s paradox—the vulnerable infant Christ, born in obscurity, who embodies a love greater than the world’s mightiest powers. This “power of love” is lifted up as more lasting, revolutionary, and transformative than any “love of power” or military-force solution. The conversation calls on believers to claim a complex faith, one that welcomes questioning and does not settle for simplistic worldviews.
Philip Amerson urges us to avoid the trap of binary thinking: we are not to believe that some people are wholly good, others wholly bad, or that God rewards some while rejecting others. “No, there is no garbage in God’s realm,” he asserts, affirming that all are children of God.
Key Takeaways:
- Resist Simplistic Narratives: Faith and life are complex. Refrain from labeling others as all-good or all-bad, and reject rhetoric that dehumanizes.
- Choose the Power of Love: True authority lies in love, not in coercion or violence; Jesus’s life and death model the ultimate paradox of powerful humility.
- Embrace Paradox and Mystery: Faith calls us into the mysteries of paradox—strength in weakness, greatness in service, hope amid darkness.
- Every Person Has Inherent Value: God’s realm includes everyone. There are no outcasts, no “garbage,” only beloved children of God.
- Live Beyond Either-Or Thinking: Move past easy divisions and be open to the complexity and diversity of human experience, especially in this season of Advent.
As you journey through Advent and into Christmas, may these reflections inspire you to nurture love, complexity, and belonging—in your life, your community, and the wider world.
Philip Amerson [00:00:01]:
Greetings.
Philip Amerson [00:00:01]:
This is Phil Amerson for the Belonging Exchange. Another brief because moment to share with you during this Advent 2025 I read a poem by Walter Wangren Jr. On the Carol of warmth and cold and I've been thinking a lot about the issue of power and authority. The email was full today encouraging me to be involved politically and I understand that I visited with friends earlier today wanting me to be engaged in one way or another to try to address the evils of our time. They are many. How can anyone believe that our society in the United States is a healthy one when the President speaks of human beings as garbage? Or when we think it is appropriate to use our power to blow up fishing boats without evidence?
Philip Amerson [00:01:08]:
Oh, perhaps they're drugs that were being.
Philip Amerson [00:01:11]:
Not coming to the United States. The boats didn't have that much fuel. But we're trying to pretend that military.
Philip Amerson [00:01:22]:
Power, the love of power, is more important than the power of love.
Philip Amerson [00:01:33]:
Call me naive. Better yet, call me a Christian believer.
Philip Amerson [00:01:39]:
One who doesn't buy into these simplistic.
Philip Amerson [00:01:42]:
Little worldviews of some are all good, some are all bad. Or belief that if I pray, God will reward me and not the other fellow who is just as much a child of God as I am.
Philip Amerson [00:01:59]:
The life we live is complex. The God we serve calls on us.
Philip Amerson [00:02:06]:
To live beyond the easy either or didactic ways, didactic dyadic thinking that there's only this way or that way.
Philip Amerson [00:02:21]:
Jesus came and gave us the paradox.
Philip Amerson [00:02:25]:
Of a tiny child born in an.
Philip Amerson [00:02:28]:
Out of the way place who paradoxically gave of his life on a cross to model something even more powerful.
Philip Amerson [00:02:42]:
Than.
Philip Amerson [00:02:43]:
The most powerful military in all history. It is the love that God offers.
Philip Amerson [00:02:55]:
To even me, to even you. May you have a blessed Advent and.
Philip Amerson [00:03:01]:
May you remember that the care that is available to you is available to everyone.
Philip Amerson [00:03:12]:
No, there is no garbage in God's realm.
Philip Amerson [00:03:17]:
All are children of God. God bless as you proceed through this.
Philip Amerson [00:03:24]:
Season of Advent and Christmas.
