"Because". How a Simple Hymn Changed the Atmosphere at a Klan Gathering

"Because": To Be and Do with Phil Amerson

In this moving episode of To Be and Do, host Phil Amerson shares a personal story that resonates deeply with anyone wrestling with questions of faith, community, and the challenges of responding to hate. Drawing on his experiences in Evansville, Indiana, in the late 1980s, Phil Amerson reflects on a pivotal moment when the Ku Klux Klan sought to recruit local residents under the guise of protecting them, following a series of attacks in the neighborhood. The episode not only provides an intimate look at how faith communities can respond to divisive forces, but it also offers listeners concrete takeaways for handling conflict, prejudice, and fear.

Three Key Takeaways from the Episode:

1. The Power of Quiet and Compassionate Presence

Rather than responding to the Klan with protest or confrontation, Phil Amerson and his faith group, Patchwork Ministries, opted for a more gentle approach, inspired by a neighbor named Stella. Instead of rallying or rebuking, they attended the Klan meeting, sat quietly among attendees, prayed, and engaged in calm conversation. This soft and steady presence, rather than aggressive activism, diffused tension and created an atmosphere where people's motivations could be gently questioned. Sometimes the most courageous action is simply showing up with compassion and listening.

2. Relationship as a Bridge for Change

Through Will Campbell’s encouragement and his own openness, Phil Amerson developed a surprising friendship with a young Klan member. The story highlights that lasting transformation often stems from genuine human relationships. Will’s advice was simple but profound: learn the names of the Klan members, not just the victims. This focus on seeing the humanity in every person—even those with whom you vehemently disagree—enabled Phil Amerson to welcome someone from the Klan into their worship, fostering an environment where change became possible.

3. Redemption Through Unexpected Gestures

The narrative culminates in a powerful moment when the young Klan member, after regularly attending worship, relinquishes both his revolver and his Klan membership card into the offering plate. This symbolic act represents an abandonment of hate and violence, a testament to the quiet influence of community, prayer, and simple acts of kindness. The episode reminds listeners that small gestures can have profound impact, and that hope is sustained by persistence, faith, and willingness to see the possibility of redemption in everyone.

Final Thoughts

This episode offers a refreshing perspective on activism and faith. Phil Amerson doesn’t shy away from the realities of racism and violence, but instead advocates for thoughtful, relational interventions. The story serves as a compelling reminder that hope often lives in the margins—in small, quiet acts, and in the courage to stand alongside those wrestling with their own beliefs.

If you’re looking for inspiration on how to respond to hostility with hope, and how to build bridges in the most difficult circumstances, this episode is a must-listen.